Democrats - Obama Presidency Oral History

Democrats

“I couldn't be both chief organizer of the Democratic Party and function as Commander-in-Chief and President of the United States,” Barack Obama reflected during his final month in office, continuing: “We did not begin what I think needs to happen over the long haul, and that is rebuild the Democratic Party at the ground level.” The 2008 election had been a triumph for the Democratic Party, including “at the ground level.” Obama won the presidency by a wide margin, propelled to victory by an expansive field operation, historic volunteer and supporter network, and “small-dollar” donations from Americans across the country. And the victory was not just Obama’s. Democrats enjoyed large majorities in the Senate and House of Representatives, and controlled a majority of state legislatures and governor’s mansions. When Obama left office in 2017, however, Democrats held fewer elected offices than at any point since the 1920s. They had lost the presidency, control of both houses of Congress, and all but 18 governorships and 11 state legislatures.  The Obama Presidency Oral History project provides wide-ranging coverage of this trajectory, helping to illuminate the transformation of the Democratic Party and its electoral coalition over the course of the Obama years. 

Supporters of Presidential Candidate Barack Obama in Grant Park on Election Night, 4 November 2008

For the 2008 election, Obama’s campaign organization—Obama for America (OFA)—had built a massive field operation, made use of new digital technologies and online social platforms, and compiled a valuable mailing list of more than ten million supporters. After Obama’s victory, advisors and strategists debated how to best transition this infrastructure into an entity that would be useful for governing, rather than campaigning. They considered preserving OFA as an independent grassroots organization, but shortly before his inauguration, Obama announced that OFA—now renamed Organizing for America—would be brought inside the Democratic National Committee (DNC), where it would mobilize support for the administration’s legislative agenda. During healthcare reform negotiations, for instance, OFA hosted national phone banks and solicited commitments from campaign supporters to volunteer in support of legislation that had stalled in Congress.

After Obama’s reelection, OFA was again redefined and restructured. Now Organizing for Action, OFA was registered as a standalone 501(c)(4) nonprofit outside of the DNC. The tax-exempt status allowed OFA to accept unlimited donations, but barred it from participating in election-related activities. During Obama’s second term, OFA worked to register Americans in healthcare insurance plans available under the Affordable Care Act, trained thousands of community organizers, and staged rallies in support of progressive causes. In project interviews, narrators discuss these activities, and reflect on the relationships between the Obama campaign and the DNC, the DNC and the Obama White House, and OFA and Democrats in Congress.

Patrick Gaspard

Ambassador and Political Advisor

Decision to integrate OFA into the DNC and concerns about autonomy and control
01:45
/ 01:45

Mitchell Stewart

Political Campaign Organizer

Decision to integrate OFA within the DNC and its impact on party dynamics
02:14
/ 02:14

Jim Messina

Political Advisor and Campaign Manager

Formation of Organizing for Action separate from the DNC
01:49
/ 01:49

Jon Carson

Public Engagement Official

Transition from 2012 campaign to leading Organizing for Action
01:57
/ 01:57

David Simas

White House Political Advisor

Relationship between the Obama administration and Democratic Party in 2014
09:22
/ 09:22

Obama's 2008 victory depended on the support of young people, non-white Americans, and college-educated white voters, and through the 2016 election, Democratic voters were significantly younger, less white, less religious, and more educated than both the Republican Party and the United States as a whole. Political advisors and campaign strategists consider these shifts in their oral histories, and reflect on contemporary enthusiasm about the effects of demographic trends on the Democratic Party's electoral prospects.

First Cabinet of President Barack Obama in the White House East Room.

From Obama’s first months in office, Republicans were hostile toward potential collaborations with the White House or congressional Democrats, and voted, nearly in unison, against the administration’s marquee legislative initiatives. Given this Republican opposition, the Obama administration’s capacity to enact policy depended on close coordination with Democrats in Congress. During the first two years of Obama’s presidency, while Democrats enjoyed a governing trifecta in Washington, Democrats used their majorities to pass a major economic stimulus package, healthcare reform, financial industry regulation, updated nutrition standards for public school meals, and other legislation. In each of these efforts, the White House worked with the Democratic congressional leadership and key congressional blocs, including the Congressional Black Caucus, the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, the New Democrat Coalition, and the conservative Blue Dog Coalition. Relations between the White House and these groups were occasionally contentious, and across the project archive administration officials, Senators, Representatives, staffers, and Washington insiders share stories of critical negotiations between the White House and Democrats in Congress. 

President Barack Obama meets with students to discuss student loan rates, in the Oval Office, July 19, 2013

The Democratic Party in Washington changed considerably during Obama’s presidency. No event contributed to that change more than the 2010 midterm elections. Though the party of the president typically suffers in midterm elections, 2010 was particularly devastating for Democrats. Republicans gained seven seats in the Senate, and more than sixty in the House, as a wave of radical “Tea Party” Republicans arrived on Capitol Hill. The midterms also shifted the midpoint of the House Democratic caucus to the political left, as dozens of moderate and conservative Democrats were defeated by Republican challengers. In project interviews, narrators reflect on the impacts of the 2010 midterms, and speak widely about major changes in the Democratic congressional caucus over the course of the Obama years, including its new geography and increased diversity, as more women, non-white, and LGBT politicians won elections and took office. 

David Axelrod

Senior Advisor to the President

Reflections on the 2010 midterm elections and Democratic losses
02:23
/ 02:23

Pete Rouse

White House Chief of Staff

Reflections on the impact of the 2010 midterms on Obama's presidency and the DNC
03:07
/ 03:07

Patrick Gaspard

Ambassador and Political Advisor

Anticipating and analyzing the 2010 midterm elections and the political climate
06:48
/ 06:48

Mitchell Stewart

Political Campaign Organizer

OFA's role and strategy in off-year and midterm elections
04:07
/ 04:07

Krysta Harden

Deputy Secretary of Agriculture

Impact of the 2010 midterm elections on USDA and rural Democrats
02:02
/ 02:02

Mona Sutphen

Deputy Chief of Staff

Reflections on President Obama's mood and staff adjustments post-midterm elections
02:32
/ 02:32

Beyond formal party structures and elected officeholders, the Obama administration regularly interacted with Democratic Party-aligned civil society organizations and grassroots activists. White House officials, for instance, regularly met with advocates under the auspices of the "Common Purpose Project," and those meetings were critical for clarifying policy priorities, coordinating congressional strategy, and managing public criticism of the administration. Many activist organizations and movements emerged over the course of the Obama years, forcing elected officials to rethink their actions, reshaping public discourse, and delivering legal and policy change. The White House often came into contact with these activists, and occasionally involved leaders in formal processes. Across the project archive, activists, advocates, and administration officials discuss these encounters, and speak widely about key movements of the period, including Occupy Wall Street; the Fight for $15; Black Lives Matter; and advocacy for LGBTQ+ rights, climate and environmental justice, gun control, student debt relief, and more.

Jennifer Palmieri

White House Communications Director

Engagement with the Obama administration through the Common Purpose meetings
01:52
/ 01:52

Melody Barnes

Domestic Policy Advisor

White House negotiations with activists on reproductive health and immigration during the ACA drafting
03:29
/ 03:29

Patrick Gaspard

Ambassador and Political Advisor

Handling labor's disappointment over the Employee Free Choice Act
03:41
/ 03:41

The Obama Presidency Oral History project’s coverage of the Democratic Party and its coalition overlaps and intersects with a number of other topic areas in the collection, including Elections and Campaigns, Republican Opposition, The People’s House, and Black Politics