Transition - Obama Presidency Oral History

Transition

The transition between the presidencies of George W. Bush and Barack Obama was historic on multiple dimensions. With more than 180,000 American military personnel then stationed in Iraq and Afghanistan, it was the first wartime transfer of power since 1968-69. It was also the first transition since September 11, 2001, after which new guidelines for presidential transfers had been codified in response to the heightened risk of terrorism. Further complicating matters, the transition took place between the summer of 2008 and the inauguration on January 20, 2009, and during that period the United States descended into the country’s worst economic crisis since the Great Depression. The Obama Presidency Oral History project provides wide-ranging coverage of these issues, and illuminates how major events, decisions, and actions taken during the Bush-Obama transition shaped the Obama presidency and the Obama years.

President Obama had called on the two former Presidents to help with the situation in Haiti. During their public remarks in the Rose Garden, President Clinton had said about President Bush, ‘I’ve already figured out how I can get him to do some things that he didn’t sign on for.’ Later, back in the Oval, President Bush is jokingly asking President Clinton what were those things he had in mind. Jan. 16, 2010

The Obama campaign began to prepare for a possible transition to the White House shortly after Obama secured the Democratic presidential nomination in June 2008. These early activities were low-profile, as the campaign was eager to avoid appearing presumptuous, or giving the impression that it was “measuring the drapes” in anticipation of a victory in November. To head the transition, Obama tapped John Podesta, Bill Clinton’s former chief of staff and the founder of the Center for American Progress, a Washington think tank and policy shop home to many Clinton administration veterans, and widely viewed as a Democratic administration-in-waiting. Podesta quietly coordinated with the Obama campaign and the Bush White House, and began to build out a network of experts and staffers to review Bush administration executive actions, develop prospective policies, and identify and vet potential political appointees.  

After Obama’s election in November, these activities ramped up, as Obama, Podesta, and other key aides expanded and formalized the transition operation. The transition was spread across offices in Washington and Chicago, and staffed by several hundred campaign field organizers, veterans of previous Democratic administrations, academics and policy experts, political strategists, and lawyers. Many of these staffers were organized into policy working groups and “agency review teams,” which assumed responsibility for the dozens of federal executive-branch agencies and offices, developed policy positions, and crafted executive actions for Obama to sign during his first days in the Oval Office. The president is responsible for filling more than 7,500 non-career positions across the federal government, more than 1,200 of which require Senate confirmation, and the transition sifted through the more than 300,000 resumes they received to vet potential appointees and shepherd them through their confirmation proceedings. In oral history interviews, narrators reflect on the construction of this transition apparatus, differentiate it from the Obama campaign, describe the strict restrictions on lobbying they implemented, outline Obama’s interest in assembling a diverse administration that “looked like America,” and recount high-profile appointments and personnel decisions. 

John Podesta

Presidential Advisor

Planning the Obama transition and lessons from the Clinton administration
06:33
/ 06:33

Elizabeth Brown

White House Staff Secretary

Organizational structure and management of the agency review process during presidential transition
02:31
/ 02:31

Brian Mosteller

Director of Oval Office Operations

Transition from campaign to Obama administration: setting up the transition office and preparing for new roles
06:52
/ 06:52

Tommy Vietor

Communications Official

Experience and challenges during the Obama-Biden transition period
02:45
/ 02:45

Stephanie Valencia

Public Engagement Official

Role in the Obama transition team and challenges faced
05:21
/ 05:21

Danielle White

Director of Scheduling

Experiences and challenges during the Obama presidential transition period
06:47
/ 06:47

These activities required regular and extensive engagement with the Bush administration. After the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, the 9/11 Commission had issued recommendations to improve the national security dimensions of presidential transitions, and many of these recommendations were formalized in the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004 (IRTPA). Bush was deeply committed to the orderly transfer of power, especially given the vulnerability of American military personnel in active combat zones, and instructed his administration to go beyond IRTPA requirements to assist the incoming administration. As soon as Obama and John McCain became the nominees of their respective parties, they began to receive regular national security briefings, and the Bush White House produced volumes describing all presidentially-appointed, Senate-confirmed federal positions, along with dozens of memos detailing actions they had taken, the reasoning behind them, and priorities in crucial areas of domestic and foreign policy. Across the Obama Presidency Oral History, Bush White House staff, as well as members of Obama’s transition team, remember the Bush administration’s approach to the process, and share memories of their collaboration. 

Josh Bolten

White House Chief of Staff

Discussion on President Bush's instructions for a smooth transition to President Obama
02:37
/ 02:37

Chris Lu

Cabinet Secretary

Challenges and cooperation during the Obama-Bush presidential transition
03:48
/ 03:48

Yohannes Abraham

Policy Advisor

Reflections on the significance of presidential transitions
03:11
/ 03:11

Coordination of this sort was particularly urgent as the financial crisis worsened throughout the autumn of 2008. Obama regularly spoke with Bush’s Treasury Secretary, Henry Paulson, to understand the actions the government was taking to stabilize the financial system, while Obama’s incoming team of economic policy experts began developing countercyclical measures to prevent further job losses, and stimulate economic growth. As the economic outlook deteriorated over the course of the transition, Obama and his legislative staff also met with lawmakers on Capitol Hill to discuss possible economic stimulus measures, and worked to prepare legislation so that it would be ready for Obama’s signature shortly after his inauguration in January. These efforts culminated in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, which Obama signed less than a month after taking office, and are discussed further on the topic page for the Financial Crisis and the Economy

President Obama at Homeland Security Council meeting in Cabinet Room of the White House to discuss the H1N1 flu, May 1, 2009.

National security was another area requiring close and sustained communication between the transition and Bush administration. After the election, president-elect Obama and incoming chief of staff Rahm Emanuel began to receive the President’s Daily Brief on national security issues, as well as regular intelligence briefings from the Director of National Intelligence and CIA. The Bush and Obama national security teams also met in the White House Situation Room to discuss major ongoing events and risks, and to conduct crisis simulations and tabletop threat exercises. The issues discussed in these sessions included the ongoing war in Iraq and the deterioration of conditions in Afghanistan, the devastating Mumbai terrorist attacks that took place in late-November, and the risk of a terrorist attack at Obama’s inauguration. In their oral histories, narrators speak widely about the transition’s focus on national security, while detailed coverage of these particular issues can be found on the topic pages for Wartime Presidency, Counterterrorism, and the Middle East

John Brennan

CIA Director

Impact of Mumbai attacks on the Obama administration's transition and counterterrorism approach
03:37
/ 03:37

Michael Morell

CIA Deputy Director

Experience briefing President-elect Obama during the transition period
10:01
/ 10:01

Michael Leiter

Counterterrorism Official

Transition and continuity at NCTC during the Obama administration's onset
11:02
/ 11:02

Jeremy Bash

Intelligence and Defense Official

Role in providing intelligence briefings during the presidential transition
02:18
/ 02:18

Derek Chollet

Foreign Policy Official

Challenges faced during the transition period due to wars, financial crisis, and cabinet selections
03:04
/ 03:04

Michèle Flournoy

Defense Policy Official

Transition experience with Secretary Gates remaining as Defense Secretary under Obama
02:19
/ 02:19

Over the course of the Obama presidency, new laws further improved and formalized presidential transition procedures, and in 2012 and 2016, the administration prepared for the possible, and actual, transfer of power. Narrators across the project archive remember these preparations, and share stories of their final days in the White House